Massimo Tadi
New Physical Transformations in Complex Development Systems:
From the City to the Metropolitan Urban Landscape.
Massimo Tadi is Professor in Architecture
Politecnico di Milano
Milan, Italy;
The air of the city makes you free. This incisive sentence was engraved on the city walls of Mainz to assert its pride to those who entered the town from the surrounding countryside for the weekly market, and who
became temporarily part of an exclusive as well as attractive society, based on a voluntary association and
provided with clear symbolic-representative forms of collective identification.
At vigil III, after one hundred strokes, by shutting up the city gates, two cultural universes were separated
completed (until the first mass the following day), both physically and symbolically: the free citizen, the
merchant, the craftsman and the student, within such gates, while the serf left outside.
Our tale begins now with the reference to a urban image (one we all know, even though belonging to the
passage to another millennium), where the city used to be symbolically an entire world and, it will continue
by investigating the transformations in the physical organization of a world that, at the turning of a new
millennium, has become a city.
From Babylon to Los Angeles, passing through Lubecca, ....., Geneve, ..........Milan, ...... This is not to
capture the stages of an evolutionary process (as some people uphold), neither it is about reading the current
arrangement of contemporary urban forms as a degeneration of those established and previously recognisable
(as other people uphold), while it is rather about investigating the current structure of widespread
metropolitan landscapes, such as a different, unstable and temporary formalization, included within the
patchy historical process of building and rebuilding of development forms of settlements, with changed and
faster rhythms of transformation.
The contemporary urban landscape seems to be organized under a different new formal order, according to
which the arrangements are unstable and floating, and the relational structure is characterized by fast
constituent transformations.
In order to grasp the arrangements complexity of the contemporary metropolitan landscape as well as work
out the enigma of its present form, it is useful to analyse thoroughly the transformation of the relation
between the urban core and its surroundings.
Such deep alteration is described by the meaning acquired by three important correlative pairs, good enough
Ð until yesterday - to define the members identity of the anthropogeographical landscape, yet today
inadequate to represent its relational complexity:
City vs. Countryside - Centre vs. Suburbia - Inside vs. Outside.
Until XXth century, the relation between the city and the countryside was articulated according to specific
matching rules and to rules of physical, symbolic and technical recognizability.
In fact, what constituted the countryside regions, was the reference background for precisely cutting out the
distinguishable figures of urban cores.
General recognizable organizations matched local connotations of the physical form, capable to express
specific architectural and organizational contents: walls, villages, towers, bridges, gates. Also ravelins, parish
churches, and minor external settlements became a built expression of the ubiquitous relation, yet always
different, that every town used to keep up with their wide territory outside the walls.
By fading the compacting logic peculiar of traditional space arrangements to the benefit of a new mode of
rarefaction of the dispositions and distribution of the physical space primary components, nowadays, we see
a deep transformation in the relation between the globality of the structures and local characterizations of
representative contents.
New instruments and procedures able to capture the forms in their transformation stages are therefore
required, in order to investigate, for planning purposes, the contemporary space in its new configuration,
unknown so far (including a new significant kinetic dimension as a dynamic sequence of multiple thresholds
of such transformation).
On the other hand, the dissolution of the correspondence between the city and the centrality, occurred
because of the progressive leakage of elements that were traditionally the important components of the city,
has caused a condition of 'loss of the centre', never happened before, in the contemporary metropolitan
landscapes.
Beside the fading of the key cultural requirement typical of the western urban tradition, it seems to
correspond physical consequences more and more apparent in the suburban stretch with low density.
For example, the reversal of the settlement balance from the previous centrality to external areas seemingly
homogenous is leading to the cancellation of the topological meaning of the relation centre/suburbia,
depriving such dialectical couple of any explanatory meaning in respect of the current physical
organizations.
Such confusion in the arrangements, due to the loss of a consolidated univocal point of reference, has caused
conflicting design attitudes, that is, on one hand, some pseudo avant-garde views praising the fragmentation
as an epochal condition; on the other hand, the resort to nostalgic evocations to mythical golden ages from
which drawing some pre-established figurative patterns.
We think that both should be opposed by the necessity of a conscious and critical design action, capable to
give an architectonic sense to a settlement structure seemingly equivalent.
Then, we need to establish new hierarchical levels in the development systems, to apply the correlative
principles in the arrangement logic and to define a new mapping able to arrange the new ones in the
development system.
In fact, we also witness the deep relativization of the third relation mentioned above: the relation 'inside vs.
outside'.
Today, this relation, is expressing itself no longer following clear and absolute rules (like in the case of the
traditional opposition between historical city and its territory and between the city and the countryside),
rather it is doing it with a wide range of local conditions, among the parties, the large enclosures, the plants
and the networks typical of the new metropolitan stretches, with no clear boundaries.
So, the changed conditions of the relation heretofore described seem to be closely related to the
transformation and substitution of the matrices that have played their role in the formal organization for the
settlement landscapes.
As a matter of fact, until the baroque age the symbolic Matrix arranges the space according to a
distinguishing principle among the parties, that is the materialization of such point of view that interprets the
universe in terms of a space both enclosed and defined.
The symbol/city arranged by this matrix stands out against the background of the uninhabited space, often
depicted in its wild aspects. The outline of the walls is the characteristic demarcative condition, a sort of
control apparatus between the inside and the outside, a sort of outline of a clear form.
Later, the Enlightenment operates a deep revision of the space organizational statutes, performing a new
topographical measurement of the reclaimed world.
We witness therefore the conceptual passage leading from the enclosed world of the previous matrix to the
infinite universe of the following structural Matrix.
The Enlightenment landscape, as in the visions and representations of such age, is passed, crossed and
measured by tracks that, blooming from the urban figure, establish the new nodes of a structure embracing
now the entire world.
On the latter principle, expressing a structural relation with the territory, in the 19th century the city creates
its own original organizational mode, known as systemic Matrix.
This organizes the particular urban nineteenth-century structure made of complex circulatory systems, with
radials and annulars, destined to give prominence and representativeness to the new impressive goods traffic
and means of transport. The ninenteenth-century urban landscape, as it appears in the representation of the
Impressionists, is characterized by roads travelled by coaches; avenues animated by the new merchant
middle class; sheltered arcades marking the triumph of a new building technique; circulation places which
become the magnificent spaces for the civil representation.
Starting from the city designed following the new urban theories, that consider the open spaces and the roads
as the new privileged elements, the systemic matrix broadens up to dimensional and relational amplifications
absorbed by the industrial city at the beginning of the 20th century.
This lays the basis for the following deep transformations that will lead to the contemporary metropolitan
distributions.
At this new passage, well unveiled by Mario Sironi, through his paintings "Costruttori" ("Builders") and
"Paesaggi urbani" ("Urban Landscapes"), the incoming known independence is foretold, later accomplished,
among open spaces, built spaces and elements of relation.
We witness now a broadening of the links and connections in a space seeming to identify itself more in the
places of movement and circulation which, no longer busy with celebrating people, show the appearance of a
vehicular traffic more and more intrusive.
We can identify this formal arrangement as "matrix by network".
Such matrix, assumed as a "topological object", appears in its articulation as made of nodes (routing centres,
emerging physical elements) and of links (poles), manifesting themselves according to different working
modes:
- as a local network of transformation, an oriented link starting from each node.
- as a global network of transformation, without orientation.
The matrix by network seems indeed to exceed both the dimensional scales (in which there were expressed
between city and countryside and between centre and suburbia) and the relational scales (where the relation
between inside and outside is outlined), ending up with manifesting itself through the new temporal scales of
the distance covered.
In the urban landscape of the spread city, the temporality of the connections seems to prevail on the spatiality
of the arrangements, this being an expression of a spatial condition structurally in transformation.
From this point of view, the physical space is no longer the interaction between built spaces, open spaces and
elements of relation (arranged in a system according to known matrices) but it is rather defined by the
temporal movements (within infrastructural networks, understood as favourite elements of the relation
between inside and outside).
The matrix by network introduces to the landscape of discrete structures, floating connections among the
parties, where sudden gaps, sequences of elements and intervals have become more important than the
elements in themselves and where the temporal dimension is the privileged condition upsetting the spatial-
temporal unity of the previous matrices.
Such metropolitan landscape that has recently entered the third millennium appears more and more as an
enigmatic shape, a labyrinth made of fragments similar to ruins, obliging us to decode and interpret its
multiple overlapping tracks, no longer immediately identifiable nowadays, in order for us to operate new
transformations provided with architectonic sense.
The architectural and urban planning looks at such hidden plots, inscribed in places and in the memory, in
order to elaborate, within the context of the contemporary urban landscape, a new correlative strategy among
the selected elements, capable to be the new foundations of the settlement structure.
The architectonic and urban planning has to define the condensation nodes of new formal aggregations, to
link the parties and fragments, to design the places giving recognizability and representative value to the
contemporary architectonic forms, and to give coherence to its modification techniques.
Bibliography
Amar, G. L'evolution de la conception de reseau. Rapt, Paris 1987.
Ascher, F. Metapolis ou l'avenir des villes. Paris Odile Jacob 1995.
Auge, M., Non-Places. Introduction to an Anthropology of Supermodernity. N.Y: Verso - 1st French edition in 1992.
AA.VV., Alta velocita', treni e stazioni. in: Domus dossier n.4, Edizioni Domus, Milano, 1996
AA.VV., TGV outil majeur de l'amenagement du territoire, atti del convegno Ville TGV Le Cresot, 11-12 ottobre 1990.
Balducci, A., Progetti e Innovazione. In: Clementi, A. (a cura di) Infrastrutture e piani urbanistici. Fraco Angeli, Milano 1996.
BCN Ecologia., Aportaciones a las alegaciones al estudio de impacto ambiental del Tren de Alta Velocidad a su paso por la ciudad
de Barcelona. Agencia Local d'Ecologia Urbana de Barcelona. Barcelona (2001)
BCN Ecologia., Prospectiva de la evoluci—n de la movilidad en Barcelona: bases para construir un nuevo modelo de movilidad
sistemico e integral. Agencia Local d'Ecologia Urbana de Barcelona. Barcelona (2003).
BCN Ecologia., Criterios de sintesis en el proceso de elaboracion de la Agenda XXI del distrito de Nou Barris. Agencia Local
d'Ecologia Urbana de Barcelona. Barcelona (2003)
BCN Ecologia., Planificacion estrategica en el Prat de Llobregat. Agencia Local d'Ecologia Urbana de Barcelona. Barcelona (2003)
Boeri, S.; Infussi F., Citta' e ferrovia, in Urbanistica n.78,
Boeri, S.; Lanzani, A.; Marini, E; Il territorio che cambia: ambienti, paesaggi e immagini della regione. edizioni, Abitare Segesta,
Milano, 1993.
Bonneville, M., Ville europeennes et internationalisation Ppsh Rhone Alpes, Lyon. (1991)
Carver, C., Cities in the suburbs. edizioni University of Toronto Press, Toronto, 1962.
Castells, M., The informational City: Informatio Technology, Economic Restructuring and urban-regional process, Edizioni Basil
Blackwel, Oxford 1989.
Castells, M., The Information Age: Economy, Society and Culture, vol. I Cambridge: Blackwell. (1997)
Castells, M., P.Hall Tecnopoles of the world. The making of twenty-first-century industrial complex, Routledge, London, (1994).
Castells, M., The Rise of the network society, Blackwell Publishers Inc. Cambridge (1996)
Chesnais M., Le renoveau de chemin de fer. Echanges ferroviares et systeme de trasport. Economica, Paris (1981)
Commissione Europea., Libro Bianco, la politica dei trasporti fino al 2010:il momento delle scelte. Unione Europea, Bruxell 2001.
Crotti, S., Interspazi: dai siti pubblici ai luoghi comuni, in P.Caputo (a cura di) Le architetture dello spazio pubblico, Edizioni Electa,
Milano (1997).
Crotti, S., Paradigmi progettuali della citta' contemporanea:verso un'architettura urbana. In: Crotti, Sergio., (a cura di) Per
un'architettura urbana. edizione a cura della Provincia di Bergamo, Bergamo 1998;
Crotti, S., Per una pratica teorica dell'architettura: ricerca e sperimentazione progettuale, in: D'Alfoso, E. (a cura), Attualita' della
forma urbana. edizioni Electa, Milano 1995.
Crotti, S., Progetti di nuove aggregazioni funzionali nei nodi di connessione infrastrutturale. Architettura, citta', connessioni: una
dialettica strutturale. In:, Territorio, n. 16/2001, edizioni Franco Angeli, Milano, (2001).
Dattner, R.; Mc Graw Hill Civil architecture: the new public infrastructure. (1995)
Dematteis, G. Nodi e reti nello sviluppo locale, in A. Magnaghi (a cura di) Il territorio dell'abitare, Edizioni F.Angeli, Milano,
(1990).
Dematteis, G. Sistemi territoriali locali e sistemi a rete. Un contributo geografico all'interpretazione delle dinamiche urbane, in C.S.
Bertuglia, Dupuy G. Les territoires de l'automobile, Anthropos, Paris, (1995).
Facchinetti, M., Corridoi infrastrutturali e trasformazioni del territorio : la pianificazione delle infrastrutture negli Stati Uniti.
Alinea. Firenze 2002.
Farinelli, F., I segni del mondo: immagine cartografica e discorso geografico. La Nuova Italia Editrice, Firenze.
Fortier, B. La citta' senza agglomerazione, in: Casabella n.599, Edizioni Electa, Milano (1993).
Gargiulo, G,. Dalle reti di citta' alla citta' a rete; il ruolo delle infrastrutture fisiche e telematiche per la citta' del XXI secolo. In:
Fondazione A.della Rocca Studi Urbanistici Vol.XXI, Ed. Giannini editore NA.
Garreau, J. Edge cities: lifes of the new frontier, New York, (1992).
Graham, S.; Marvin, S., Telematics and the city. Electronic spaces, urban places. Routledge, London (1998).
Gutierrez et al., Accesibilidad en la Union Europea: un analisis comparativo segun modos de transporte. Estudios de Transportes y
Comunicaciones, num. 70, Ministerio de Economia, Madrid (1996).
Mitchell, W. J. City of bits. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA (1995).
Monestiroli, A., (a cura di). Il centro altrove: periferie e nuove centralita' nelle aree metropolitane. edizioni Electa; Triennale di
Milano, Milano, 1995.
Mu–oz, F.; Nello, Oriol La produzione delle infrastrutture in Spagna e Catalogna: politiche e attori, inerzie e sfide per un territorio
in transizione. In Dematteis, G.; Governa, F., Contesti Locali e Grandi Infrastrutture. Politiche e Progetti in Italia e in Europa.
FrancoAngeli, Milano (2001).
Mu–oz, F., The Multiplied city. Metropolis of territoriants. In Musco, F., Architecture, Landscape, (75-109). Istituto Universitario di
Architettura di Venezia, IUAV-SdS Venezia (2002).
Newton, P.; Hall, P.; Nijkamp, P., The future of urban form. Routledge, London 1989
Onda, F., Grandi progetti in Europa; tendenze, vincoli e opportunita'. Tecnology Review, Londra 1993;
Perego, F. La sfida dei nodi urbani. in L'Arca, n. 62. Milano 1992.
Petitot, J., (a cura di) centrato/acentrato. In: Enciclopedia Einaudi, Vol. II, edizioni Einaudi To, 1981.
Petitot, J., (a cura di) locale/globale. In: Enciclopedia Einaudi, Vol. VIII, edizioni Einaudi To, 1981.
Pucci, P., L'evoluzione concettuale della nozione di rete. in: I nodi infrastrutturali: luoghi e non luoghi metropolitani. Edizioni
F.Angeli, Milano 1996.
Rosentiehl, P., (a cura di) Rete. In: Enciclopedia Einaudi, Vol. XI, edizioni Einaudi To, 1981.
Rueda, S., Ecologia Urbana. Barcelona y su regi—n metropolitana como referentes. Beta Editorial Barcelona (1995).
Rueda, Salvador., Barcelona ciudad mediterranea, compacta y compleja. Una vision de futuro mas sostenible. Ayuntamiento de
Barcelona (2003).
Sassen, S. Cities in a world economy, Columbia University Press (1991);
Tadi, M., Un metodo generativo applicato ai nuovi sistemi infrastrutturali complessi, per la definizione di nuovi nuclei di
condensazione della forma urbana in:, Territorio, n.20/2002, edizioni Franco Angeli, Milano, (2002).
Tadi, M., I paesaggi intermittenti della percorrenza tecnologica. Dalla materialita' delle connessioni all'immaterialita' dei
collegamenti, connotazioni tecnologiche della citta' contemporanea. in: Zanni, F., (a cura di) Architettura, progetto, reti, edizioni
Clup, Milano, 2002.
Tadi, M., Architetture in movimento: Waterways Strade d'acqua e recapiti urbani. in: Recuperare n.36, Alberto Greco edizioni,
Milano (2003).
Tadi, M., Architetture in movimento: Gates L'Architettura dei nuovi approdi multiscalari. in: Recuperare n.34, Alberto Greco
edizioni, Milano (2003).
Tadi, M., Nodi infrastrutturali e processi generativi per il progetto della struttura insediativi contemporanea in:, Territorio, n.
25, edizioni Franco Angeli, Milano (2003).
Tadi, M., Tre casi di studio: Reti infrastrutturali e nodi d'interscambio, per una progettazione orientata. in:, Territorio, n.
16, edizioni Franco Angeli, Milano(2001).
Tadi, M.; Zanni, F., Architettura e disegno urbano. Edizioni Clup, Milano 2002
Ventura, N., Stazioni ferroviarie per la citta' d'oggi. in Casabella n. 606, Edizioni Electa. Milano 1993.
Venturi R., Brown Scott d., Izenour S. Learnig from Las Vegas. The MIT Press, Cambridge MA, 1997.
Virilio, P., Lo spazio critico. Parigi, 1985
Virilio, P., La freccia del tempo, in Domus dossier n.4. Edizioni Domus. Milano, 1996.
Zanni, F., La strada come regola urbana: Ildefonso Cerda, in Tadi, Massimo, (a cura di) Scritti di architettura, Edizioni CUSL,
MI(1998).
Zanni, F., Approdi: architettura dei nodi lacuali di interconnessione, in: Recuperare l'edilizia n. 36. Alberto Greco editore, Milano,
2003.
Zanni, F., Verso uno spazio urbano dinamico, in: : Territorio, n.25, Franco Angeli, Milano, 2003.
Zanni, F., "Nodi infrastrutturali urbani. I waterfront", in: Recuperare l'edilizia n. 36 2003, Alberto Greco editore;
Zanni, F., Condizioni contestuali per il progetto urbano nella citta' generica, in: : Territorio, n.20, Franco Angeli, Milano, 2003;
Zanni, F., (a cura di), Architettura, Progetto, Reti. Edizioni Clup, Milano 2002
Zanni, F., Architettura e disegno urbano, una ricerca applicata, in: "Territorio", n.19, Franco Angeli, Milano, 2001.
Zanni, F.; Bazzi, A; Scevola, C. (a cura di), Il territorio delle Ferrovie Nord Milano: morfologie, tendenze, progetti. Guerini, Milano,
1994.
Zanni, F.; Scevola, C (a cura di), Vie di ferro nella citta' policentrica lombarda. Guerini, Milano, 1993.
Webber M.M. Order and Diversita': Community without propinquity, from Cities and Space: the future use of urban land. John
Hopins Press, Baltimore, 1963.
© Copyright: resarch paper : Massimo Tadi; web page: Archiport.it. All Rights Reserved. Unless otherwise noted, all materials contained in this Site are copyrighted and may not be used.